Last week I headed-over to Shrivenham with other members of the club to take the part of the French in a Waterloo refight using Bloody Big Battles. We were facing a tough fight against some top notch military strategists and the author of the rules. So we did what anyone do - we reached for maths and spreadsheets.
The plan
Having refought this battle a few times we had a few possible plans in mind.
- A left hook taking Hougoumont, out-flanking the ridge and taking the Brussels road.
- Grabbing the farms and then moving against the ridge.
- A right hook taking La Haye Saint and Papelotte before crossing the ridge.
We also made a few assumptions in making our plan
- We could outshoot the Allies if we managed to mass our guns but needed to keep moving not get bogged down.
- The farms would be strong positions with the Allies best units. Hougoumont likely the toughest of all.
- Grouchy would not arrive but the Prussians would, possibly quite early.
- The ridge would provide shelter from our guns and could be tricky to cross. In fact the brief made it clear we could charge from one side to the other, making that easier.
- Our right hook plan was the most likely to be a success given the photos we'd seen
So having viewed the table we decided on a variant of right hook plan;
- II Corps (Nigel) would screen Hougoumont and attack the ridge
- IV Corps (Robin) would assault La Hay Saint then attack the ridge
- I Corps (Adam)would attack Papelotte then also cross the ridge. The Guards would support IV Corps
- Much of our Cav (me) and the Young Guards would hold Placenoit and delay the Prussians .
The execution
| Start positions from the Hougoumont side |
| Deployment on my flank |
| La Hay Saint in our sights |
| II Corps ay Hougoumont |
The day
From the French side we felt we'd exceeded Napoleons performance on the day, but did have the advantage of hindsight and spreadsheets.
It was certainly a fun day and my first game in an active military establishment. There were some nice side chats about BBB, history, gaming, and the fickleness of dice. All seemed keen for further games, which is the mark of a successful event. Big thanks to our hosts for the venue, hosting and friendly spirit.
Stu, good to meet you, and congratulations on a gallant French performance. I agree your team managed to make it an even "nearer run thing" than Napoleon did. Obviously he was missing Berthier, who I imagine knew how to wield a spreadsheet.
ReplyDeleteAlas the Difference Engine was too late to save them from defeat
DeleteGreat to have a view from the French side there Stu:)! Certianly a great day out and fingers crossed we can get another one in before Xmas, as mooted during and after the game.
ReplyDeleteWe're looking at dates ATM. I'll be in touch to see if we can find one that works
DeleteVery interesting game - if only Napoleon had Excel at the real battle!
ReplyDeleteSounds and looks like a great re-fight. I was impressed with your spreadsheet logging the planned moves for the various formations under your different plans.
ReplyDeleteIt's interesting isn't it that in the end you do variations of Napoleon's plan and try to avoid squandering the arme blanche. Having the knowledge of hindsight that the most likely arrival on the right will be Prussian not French is a help, but also a hindrance.
Best wishes, James
As the commander on the British left wing, I saw the French deploy all that cavalry there and really thought they were going to descend on me and roll up my flank. I reckon they would have had a good chance of doing so. Worth playing it again just to see that tried!
DeleteI considered it but did nt as 1) That would give the Prussians free reign and Cav does nt fight that well vs inf. But would be good to trey as its worked in other refights
DeleteOf course it would depend a bit on which Prussians turned up when and where. If they caught the French cavalry in flank or rear at a crucial moment, then indeed not only could they save the Allied left wing but also Plancenoit might have been at serious risk.
Delete